A Familiar Face for a Struggling Offense?
The Philadelphia Eagles offense hasn’t looked quite right lately. While the defense remains strong, the offensive rhythm that once made this team unstoppable under Nick Sirianni and Jalen Hurts seems to have faded.
So the question naturally arises — should the Eagles bring back Frank Reich as offensive coordinator?
Frank Reich, the mastermind behind the 2017 Super Bowl–winning offense, remains one of the most respected play-callers in team history. Under his guidance, Carson Wentz was an MVP candidate, and Nick Foles delivered a playoff run for the ages. Since leaving Philly, Reich’s NFL journey has seen mixed results — a decent stint in Indianapolis followed by a short-lived tenure in Carolina — but his offensive mind has never been in doubt.
Why Frank Reich Makes Sense
1. Proven Chemistry with Nick Sirianni
Before Reich became the Colts’ head coach, he and Nick Sirianni worked side by side in Indianapolis. Their philosophies align — creative route combinations, tempo offense, and a heavy RPO (run-pass option) system. Bringing Reich back could reignite that synergy and take pressure off Sirianni’s play-calling duties.
2. A Perfect Fit for Jalen Hurts
Reich’s ability to tailor an offense to his quarterback’s strengths could benefit Jalen Hurts immensely. The Eagles’ star thrives in structure but needs balance — a coach who can blend mobility, quick reads, and efficient play action. Reich’s offenses have always been QB-friendly, emphasizing rhythm and adaptability.
3. Locker Room Credibility
Reich commands instant respect. Veterans like Jason Kelce, Lane Johnson, and Brandon Graham all know what he brings — calm leadership and accountability. For a team that’s appeared emotionally inconsistent in 2025, that steadiness could make all the difference.
Why It Might Not Work
1. Sirianni’s Pride and Control
Let’s be honest — bringing in Reich would shift the spotlight. Would Sirianni relinquish control of the offense? Or would it create friction in the coaching hierarchy? The Eagles’ head coach must decide if he’s ready to delegate again.
2. Different Personnel, Different Era
The 2017 offense worked because of its depth and versatility — multiple tight ends, elite blocking, and role-specific receivers. Today’s roster looks different. Reich would need to re-imagine his playbook for a faster, more vertical offense.
3. Fan Expectations
Philly fans love nostalgia, but they also have short patience for “what if” experiments. If the move doesn’t immediately yield results, the pressure could be immense — both for Reich and for Sirianni.
Final Take: The Case for a Reunion
If the Eagles’ offense continues to stall, Frank Reich represents both the logical and emotional solution. He’s battle-tested, respected, and deeply familiar with the Eagles’ DNA.
While there’s risk in revisiting the past, sometimes the best way forward is to reconnect with what worked before.
If the front office believes that Jalen Hurts still has another level to reach — and that this offense just needs a spark — bringing back Frank Reich could be the move that brings the fire back to Philly.
🦅 What Do You Think, Philly Fans?
Would you welcome Frank Reich back as offensive coordinator, or should the Eagles look elsewhere?
Drop your comments below or join the conversation on StraightShooterSports.com — where real fans talk real football.
